The World According to Arnie – Hercules in New York (1970)

Hercules in New York Title

Growing up I didn’t watch a lot of TV or movies. I spent a lot of my time outdoors playing sports, at the beach or just tooling about on my BMX with my mates. When I did watch movies, I wasn’t in to fantasy or horror movies like a lot of other kids of the 80’s. Movies I liked pretty much fell in to three categories; sports themed movies like Karate Kid, Rocky or Major League; adventures like Back to the Future, Star Wars or Indiana Jones; and Arnie. Lots and lots of Arnie. Thankfully for me, my Dad didn’t’ really give a shit about the ratings system, and frequently rented me R18 ultra violent films like Commando, The Running Man and Predator. Seeing this blood and carnage at an early age, it’s a wonder that I’ve become the well adjusted person I am today.

Watching Arnie films is one of the many fond memories I have of my childhood, and in a bid to recapture my long lost youth, I have decided to celebrate the life and times of one Arnold Alois Schwarzenegger by reviewing all his films (which he has had at least a significant role in). Quite a few I haven’t actually seen, particularly early in his career. Some with good reason. Like Hercules in New York for instance.

Hercules in New York Poster

God this movie is a piece of shit. It’s terribly acted, the storyline sucks, it’s completely shoddy and worst of all, after about 30 minutes (being generous) it’s fucking boring. The version I watched contains Arnies original dialogue, and actually made me wish I’d watched the dubbed version.

Hercules in New York 1Hercules (Arnie, billed as Arnold Strong) is as dumb as dogshit and a whining little bitch to boot. On Mt Olympus, his father Zeus (some bloke in a fake beard), surrounded by supposedly hot women that all look like they sucked a fat blokes sweaty cock to get the role, forbids Hercules to travel to the mortal plane so he can letch on chicks. This is a significantly wise move on Zeus’ part because he recognises that Hercules is an epic moron and the temptation of smoking hot mortal poon would be too much for his tiny pea brain to handle. But Herc is a little cunt and pisses off anyway. Through a series of shitty hijinks he winds up as a professional wrestler with an annoying fucking comedic sidekick called Pretzy (some irritating “oy vey” cliché ridden twat). He’s nicknamed Pretzy because he sells pretzels at the wharf. Fucking hell. There’s also a love interest (some overacting untalented wench never to be heard from again) and a wiseguy manager (some… ah, fuck it. Who cares?). Herc fights sailors, competes against athletes, fights a bloke in a bear outfit, loses his not very godlike abilities, takes his shirt off a lot and completely mangles the English language.

Hercules in New York 6 There’s nothing redeeming about ‘Hercules in New York’. It truly is a terrible film. Arnie regrets appearing in it. Me too. Cause I had to watch this piece of shit for his retrospective. Sometimes terrible films can be hilarious, but apart from one or two mildly amusing scenes, it really is incredibly boring, and worse than that, the Hercules character is fucking annoying. There is some amusement (maybe bemusement is a better word) to be had from the production. The direction by Arthur Allan Seidelman is utterly inept. At one point in a conversation scene, the close up shot of an actor is completely obscured by the entire back of Arnies head. The escaped bear looks exactly like what it is; a bloke in a cheap bear costume. It’s all shot at a long distance with a zoom lense to try to obscure that fact, but unless you’re an inbred mongoloid raised in a hidden cellar in Austria, it’s blatantly obvious. The fight scenes are horribly staged. People frequently fall down from hits that obviously do not connect. The sound is worth a few chuckles. The scenes on Mt Olympus are filled with dialogue obscuring background noise (which is a good thing) including street noise such as the honking of car horns and barking dogs.

Hercules in New York 5 The “acting”, for want of a better word, is utter garbage from everyone involved. Arnie, who was just 23 at the time, looks to be struggling when he is required to recite anything longer than a four word sentence. It’s no wonder they dubbed him. The hammy cunt Pretzy is so unbearably over the top you want Arnie to pummel him with his mammoth fists, and the “love interest” reacts in a bewildering fashion to almost every situation. The most irritating thing about this whole festuring bowel movement is Seidelmans insistence on inserting goofy fucking reaction shots, particularly from Pretzy, who constantly has his mouth agape like he’s attempting to swallow a watermelon whole. The love interest also has at least two completely baffling reaction shots, one when Arnie wrestles the bear, and the other when Arnie removes his shirt on Broadway. But despite these being incredilbly irritating, they at least elicit an emotional response, which breaks up the sheer, unbridled monotony of watching Arnie butcher his lines and stumble in to one pathetically stupid situation after another. And I do mean stumble. The ridiculously huge bastard actually stumbles during a romantic walk with the love interest. He knows it and doinks his palm on his forehead and laughs. And Seidelman doesn’t give a shit. Cut! Print! Next scene! Un-fucking-believable.

Hercules in New York 4 The music also becomes irritating as fuck about 30 seconds in to the movie. And it’s repeated constantly throughout the movie. It’s a faux comedic score, supposed to highlight the comedy, but only succeeds in annoying the fuck out of you.

Overall, this is not an auspicious debut for the Austrian Oak, and it’s understandably one he’d rather forget. But all legends must start somewhere, and at the very least, it’s a reminder that, especially during his body-building days, Arnie was fucking massive. As thick as two planks. But massive nonetheless.


For an idea of how inept this flick is, take a look at this.

Next up, Arnie will be back and this time he rubs his massive shoulders with The Dude and The Flying Nun in “Stay Hungry”.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Judge Droid

In between refining my procrastination skills I talk a lot of shit about movies and such.

27 responses to “The World According to Arnie – Hercules in New York (1970)”

  1. lordbronco says :

    Hmmm-I believe this movie is as bad as you say, I honestly do. But it does make me question whether you are going to be even-handed when you view Clash of the Titans…
    I’m just saying, perhaps this movie will sour your objectivity towards Olympic Gods in general-especially whenst meddling in the affairs of Humans…
    Just a slight concern.

    • Droid says :

      I’m actually warming to the idea of Titans. Granted its directed by that useless sack of shit Surrender Hulk but it looks like good idiotic fun.

      I have to see the Harryhausen one first though.

      • herr milflover says :

        I watched the Harryhausen one a few weeks ago, I’m still trying to do a review of it and I’m starting to lose interest in finishing it… I have a few points I want to get across but am having trouble making them into a coherent whole. You can have the honors if you want and I’ll just throw my opinions in the comments.

  2. Tom_Bando says :

    I have seen it. It IS as bad as he sez. Tres Poo-poo as the French say.

  3. herr milflover says :

    Holy shit, that’s just too fucking funny! I was looking for that bear fight and found this!

  4. M. Blitz says :

    Very funny review. I believe you that it’s awful, but the movie sounds seriously amazing nonetheless…. Bear fight! Pretzy!

  5. Tom_Bando says :

    I saw this on something like AMC when they were showing really bad movies one weekend. Or USA. I forget. I didn’t/couldn’t put up w/ it for more than 20 minutes at a time-but saw more than enough. Truly a legacy of shame.

  6. Barfaloopy says :

    You were more than kind with your review Droid. I’ve seen this and it indeed sucks. Looking forward to Stay Hungry. A huge step up for his career from the “acting” in this dreck.

  7. Jarv says :

    That is fucking funny

    I think you need to see the dubbed version to appreciate this properly.

  8. Jarv says :


    I love that film, stupid clockwork owl and all.

    • herr milflover says :

      The movie didnt age particularly well but is overall still watchable, but that fucking Owl is one of the things I wanted to rant about…. dear god I had completely forgotten about it since last seeing it so many years ago, and it nearly ruined it for me when I saw it again. I hope the remake ditches it.

  9. MORBIUS says :

    CLASH OF THE TITANS, I think BUBO (the owl) was previously engaged and not able to commit to the remake.

    I’ve never seen Hercules in New York, and because of your review I never will….thanks Droid.

    Did you find ‘Carnival in Rio’ (or whatever its called) on the internets? If so, please review it. I saw it years ago and would like to read your take on it.

    • Droid says :

      I’ve looked for it Morbius, without success. But I’ll keep looking for it, because I’m very interested to see it.

      • DocPazuzu says :

        If I’m not mistaken, Carnival in Rio was upped at Cinemageddon not too long ago.

      • Jarv says :

        Doc- you’re the man to ask about this- how do I improve my ratio at Cinemaggedon.

        It’s been yonks since I used it and I’ve had to get a new account. I’m nearing the 5GB before they start getting pissy about uploading.

    • DocPazuzu says :

      Seed, baby, SEEEED!!!
      Actually, I got lucky and downloaded a few DVDs which were very popular for a while which upped my ratio something fierce. Since then it’s been in steady decline and I’m approaching the dreaded 0.45 limit despite being a VIP (bought myself the rank with my credit points) and am seriously considering paying the ten quid which would make me lifer and impossible to demote below “user” (four simultaneous downloads).

      I’ve found so many amazing things there and constantly find my jaw dropping almost every time I check for updates that it’s become an essential part of my film consumption.

      • Jarv says :

        I’ve got things from it that I’ve not been able to get anywhere else- Vice Squad was the most recent one. I’m still below the 5GB limit on this new account, but I’m certain to crash it in the next few days.

        I may pay the £10 as well. Sorely considering it

  10. koutchboom says :

    So is pumping Iron part of this retrospective as well?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: