Droid defines the Decades best movies – #9 Requiem for a Dream (2001)

Requiem for a Dream Poster Through my sheer exhaustive dedication to procrastination, my thunder has once more been stolen by Jarv’s review (found here). His is a good review, and he makes many of the same points that I was going to. So while touching on those briefly, I will try to make this a review that works alongside his one, so as not to repeat and bore you all to tears.

The plot in brief. Based on the novel by Hubert Selby Jr, ‘Requiem’ follows four characters from Brighton Beach who struggle to better themselves and find meaning in their empty lives through a variety of drugs. Harry (Jared Leto), his girlfriend Marion (Jennifer Connelly), his best friend Tyrone (Marlon Wayans) and his mother Sara (Ellen Burstyn). None of these characters have jobs, have far too much time on their hands, and aren’t equipped to handle the tedium of a life without meaning or purpose. For three of them it’s a conscious decision to escape from reality, while for Sara, it comes down to her desire to appear on a television game show, to wear her red dress and relive her last memory of happiness.

Requiem for a Dream 2 This is Darren Aronofsky’s best film thus far. Pi was great, and The Wrestler, while a good film, just felt a little paint by numbers for someone of his talent. The Fountain was a swing and a miss for me, but I have nothing but admiration for that film, because it was one hell of a swing. Here he uses a lot of visual trickery, but it feels organic. The visuals serve a purpose, and are meant to represent something. It’s not just stylized for the sake of it. The speeded up footage when Sara takes the pills for the first time or the flurry of images when anyone takes the drugs are meant to visually represent that act and effect of doing these drugs. And it works.

Requiem for a Dream 4 I want to point out a couple of shots that have stayed with me since first watching it. First is the transition from Summer to Fall (I say transition, but it’s more like Fall slamming in to Summer). When Tyrone escapes the car after the shootout, Aronofsky straps the camera to Wayans and we stare directly into his face as the terrified Tyrone runs for his life. This scene and particularly this shot amazed me when I saw it at the cinema, and after seeing it a number of times since, it still does. It’s a completely unexpected kick in the balls after the rosy and dream like first act. These lives come crashing down to earth with a thud, and it only gets worse from here.

Requiem for a Dream 3 The other shot I want to point out is actually two shots, during the scene when Harry “suggests” that Marion could get some money by sleeping with her shrink (the wonderfully grotesque Sean Gullete, star of ‘Pi’). Throughout the scene Aronofksy has them in a two shot, showing the desperation of Harry as he tries to rationalise with Marion (and himself) why she needs to do it. The first shot is once Marions pleas don’t work, she accepts and understands what price must be paid for her addiction. The look on her face is of a life that was clinging to hope finally dashed. The second shot is immediately after and it’s a two shot of her sitting next to Harry, but Aronofsky has positioned his camera and framed Harry out of view, isolating Marion in her loneliness and despair. It’s a heartbreaking scene.

Requiem for a Dream 5 Which brings me to the acting. Everything Jarv said about these four actors is on the money, so I won’t repeat him. But I don’t think he properly gave enough credit to Burstyn. She is completely and utterly amazing as Sara. Her panic and desperation for something more out of her dreary life is almost impossible to watch. The scene Jarv pointed out, where Harry twigs to his mothers diet pills is one of the most raw and emotional performances I’ve seen. Years of fear and loneliness, and the desperate need for validation from a bunch of old ladies who sit on fold out chairs on the pavement comes flooding out and her monologue is gut-wrenching. “I’m somebody now.” And at the end of the scene when Harry essentially says goodbye to his mother for the last time (he has no intention of bringing Marion over for dinner), it’s him giving up on her. He’s not strong enough to save himself, let alone someone else. Hers is a powerful performance and while I don’t want to harp on it, the fact that Julia Roberts beat her for Best Actress is one of the biggest injustices in the history of the Oscars. Not that we care about such things. I just hate that they gave it to the Cheshire Cat for an annoying performance in a shit film.

Requiem for a Dream 1 In the end, the destruction of these characters is not a pleasant experience. But it’s an important one. If I ever have kids (that I know of), around their early to mid teens I’m going to haze them with this film. This is what you get when you dabble with drugs, you little shits. My version of the scared straight program. Jarv pointed out that he suspects that Aronofsky sets up his characters so he can destroy them later. I don’t completely agree. I see the arc of the movie as a representation of the arc of drug abuse. It’s all fun and easy at the start, but by the time you get dependant, bad things start to happen to you. And you either end up in jail, in a nuthouse having electricity jolted directly into your head, bumping ass in front of a braying hoard of neanderthals or qualifying for the Special Olympics. It’s a cautionary tale that’s not just about drugs, but also about pursuing meaning and purpose in your life. None of these characters have it. They have small dreams, but no will to pursue them. Sara lasts on her diet for one day before she goes to the doctor. Harry makes a plan for a store for Marion, and moves are made (we see via photos), but nothing comes of it. These are hopeless characters and their fate, while unjustifiably cruel, is of their own making. Sara we pity most of all because her addiction comes through naiveté as much as any conscious decision.

‘Requiem for a Dream’ is a masterpiece, and would be higher on my list if it weren’t so damn depressing and harrowing. But my love for feelgoodery keeps this at #9. It’s by no means an easy watch, but I revisit it every two or three years. It’s as effective today (after just watching it) as it was the first time I saw it.

The list so far…

#10 – The Descent (2005)

#11 – Unbreakable (2000)

#12 – Best in Show (2000)

#13 – Open Range (2003)

#14 – The Royal Tenenbaums (2001)

#15 – Bad Santa (2003)

#16 – The Hurt Locker (2009)

#17 – Where The Wild Things Are (2009)

#18 – Kingdom of Heaven (2005) Directors Cut

#19 – High Fidelity (2000)

#20 – Friday Night Lights (2004)

#21 – Frequency (2000)


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

About Judge Droid

In between refining my procrastination skills I talk a lot of shit about movies and such.

12 responses to “Droid defines the Decades best movies – #9 Requiem for a Dream (2001)”

  1. Droid says :

    BTW, I’ve probably confused the issue by using that shot of Leto and Connelly, but that’s not the scene I’m talking about.

  2. Jarv says :

    I don’t want to harp on it, the fact that Julia Roberts beat her for Best Actress is one of the biggest injustices in the history of the Oscars. Not that we care about such things. I just hate that they gave it to the Cheshire Cat for an annoying performance in a shit film.


    Well fucking said

  3. Jarv says :

    Good review-

    I think you could wax lyrical about hundreds of shots from this film- the panaroma of the old bints outside the apartment with the frustrated postie, the pier (I know the painting now- It’s Jack Vettriano), the paper aeroplanes (a gorgeous visual image), the soft focus of Ty’s mother. The curling into the foetal position at the end.

    Fuck, man, this film is superb.

  4. MORBIUS says :

    After reading all that, I should probably look for the Bargain Basement copy of Requiem I purchased years ago but somehow never got around to viewing.

    A little perplexed by this…

    “…where Harry twigs to his mothers diet pills…”

    I found this…’ twig Verb. To understand, to realise’…but uncertain as to its context in your sentence’…or does twigs have a different meaning?

    …where Harry understands/realises to his mothers diet pills…

    Also, anytime I see/read Jennifer Connolley, my mind immidiately goes to the scene of her ‘riding’ the mechanical hobby horse in Career Opportunities….is that bad?

  5. koutchboom says :

    Nice review, but no mention of the music? The score for this is still amazing, that sticato string stuff is the sound of nightmares.

  6. Toadkillerdog says :

    What a strange co-inky-dinky, I saw this movie on showtime this weekend! I had heard about it for years, so I was looking forward to seeing it. I had a mixed reaction to it. I thought it was very well thought out and executed. I thought all of the performances were damned good, but I was put off by what I saw as directorial flourishes. The Spkie Lee moving sidewalk trick when Wayans was running, to the Connelly elevator thing, to the over use of the eye dilation and blood for the drugs, it was to me a director who had a good idea if he used it once, but got carried away. I did think the fuzzy way he shot Burtsyn when she was high was great. I hated the fridge turning into a monster though. I loved Burstyn’s work on the bus and later at the building, that felt absolutely real, just a magnificent scene. I was a bit underwhelmed by her ‘i’m somebody’ type speech though, just felt a bit too stagey not too mention done before. Overall though , I do agree Burstyn deserved the Oscar. I did not feel soul crushed at the movie, I thought it was truly well conceived and written, I just can not rate it very high on my best of decade list because the flourishes I mentioned tended to take me out if the flick. But I recognize that it has some truly outstanding moments and I am glad I saw it. Good review BTW.

  7. Jarv says :

    Twig in this context means “realise”

  8. Jarv says :

    ” I did not feel soul crushed at the movie”

    You hard-hearted soul.

    • Toadkillerdog says :

      Ha! My heart is encased in USMC approved impervium!
      But seriously, of all the characters. Mrs Goldfarb is the most tragic. The other three can comeback from their personal abyss, but she is electro shocked out of her mind.

      I loved that Keith David line ” I know it’s pretty but I didn’t bring it out for air”

      • koutchboom says :

        In the book there is more to that scene, but not in the book, the ass-to-ass scene. It always bothers me thats how people remember this film. Fucking college kids.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: