Droid wants to live in a world without ‘The Invention of Lying’



‘The Invention of Lying’ has a premise packed with such comic potential that, as you watch it meander aimlessly along, you wonder how it could’ve gone so wrong.

Gervais stars as Mark Bellison, who inhabits an alternate universe where mankind hasn’t developed the ability to lie.  There is only truth in this universe.  There isn’t even a word for something that isn’t true.  It just is or isn’t.

The movie begins with Bellison on a first date with Anna (Jennifer Garner), who promptly informs him that although he seems nice, she finds him unattractive, not successful enough and an unsuitable genetic match for procreation.  He takes this news as a given.  He’s used to these types of comments in a world where no one tells a lie.

Bellison is a screenwriter for Lecture Films, who produce films that feature a narrator looking into camera and telling the story of a historical event.  Because there’s no lying, there’s no fiction.  I wondered why the films weren’t more like historical recreations like the films ‘Gettysburg’, ‘Amadeus’, or ‘The Patriot’ (that last one’s a joke by the way).  But then I applied logic and realised that it would require actors, and that the people in this world are unable to pretend to be anything but themselves.



Co-writer/co-director pair Ricky Gervais and Matthew Robinson have applied strict logic to every aspect of this world, which makes you appreciate it on an intellectual level, but the world is so dour and unappealing, both visually and emotionally, that we don’t embrace the characters or the story.

Bellison is fired from Lecture Films because he’s responsible for writing the biggest box office bomb of all time, called The Black Plague.  No matter that it doesn’t appear that these films would cost anything to make, since it’s a man sitting on a chair reading out loud, but that’s beside the point.  It’s not his fault, he claims.  The 1300’s is the worst century to have, because nothing happened.

Bellison owes $800 rent, but only has $300 in his account.  At the bank something triggers in his brain.  He asks for $800.  The bank teller assumes it must be a system error, and gives him the money.  Bellisons world has changed.  He can lie.

This is where the film should really take off.  Remember Groundhog Day, and the first scenes where Bill Murray discovers that he’s living that same day over and over again?  There is a real sense of panic and desperation in those scenes.  Everything he knows is crashing down around him.  Murray’s manic energy is hilarious and more importantly, a believable reaction to an extreme situation.  When Bellison discovers that he can lie, something that no one else in history has ever done, how does he react?  He wanders over to a bar to discuss it with the bartender and his alcoholic mate.  There’s no sense of amazement or fear of his new ability.  It’s like discovering one day that you can read peoples minds, and thinking “Oh, that’s handy. I wonder what’s on TV.”



The blame must fall on Gervais and Robinson.  Each scene flickers with potential, but never takes off.  The film plays as an Alexander Payne-esque dramedy, when it should’ve been played more for laughs.

The performances lack energy.  Gervais plays the character as cheerless and miserable, and it sucks any enjoyment from the film.  Once he discovers the ability to lie, he uses it for personal gain in the hope that money and success will make him happy, and that Anna will consider him a more suitable “genetic match”.  But the characters and the world they inhabit are so unlikable that you just don’t care.

The only difference between the films reality and ours is the ability to lie.  So why does everyone blurt things out unprovoked like they have Tourette’s?  A restaurant host says “I’m intimidated by you” when greeting Garner.  A waiter says “I took a sip from your drink” and “She’s out of your league”.  Bellisons secretary says “I’m overqualified” and “I loathe you”.  I understand that these people think these things and can’t lie, but they must have the ability to control the things they say.  They aren’t just mouthpieces for every thought that passes through their brain.  The characters don’t behave like normal human beings would (with the inability to lie), and are nearly all unpleasant.



There’s also number of strange cameos in the film that prove distracting.  It’s as if they missed the ‘Extras’ boat, and were desperate to associate themselves with Gervais’ next project.

The more I think about this film, the more disappointed I am.  I had high hopes due to the hilarious ‘Extras’ and ‘The Office’, as well as the mildly entertaining ‘Ghost Town’.  It’s definitely a missed opportunity, and it proves to be Gervais’ first failure.

If you want to see this kind of film done properly, watch ‘Groundhog Day’ again.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Judge Droid

In between refining my procrastination skills I talk a lot of shit about movies and such.

9 responses to “Droid wants to live in a world without ‘The Invention of Lying’”

  1. xiphos0311 says :

    Droid could I impose on you to make some posts on Twitch about Cricket, Australian rules football and soccer for that matter? A mouth breather needs to be knocked down and we are in the middle of doing it and your help would be appreciated.

    What happened was some people, me included, made a couple of posts about Baseball and this bleeding cunt named flickapoo acted like a flaming hemroid about them. In responce I made a series of posts about sports and dickface acted dickier so then everybody got in on it.

    I think it would be funny if you dropped in post or two about cricket. To bad Jarv is using some of his 300 days off. Another argument about the Ashes would hit the spot.

    Thanks in advance if you help.Nice review by the way. It makes me want to see this movie even less then I did before. I don’t get what so great about Rickey Gervais. I guess I should get around to watching the British Office.

  2. koutchboom says :

    I can’t believe Droid nay said his comedy god Gervais. Expect his wrath soon. Your going to wake up in the middle of the night sweating just hearing that giggling in your head all night and day.

  3. koutchboom says :

    Sounds like if boglin boy Ricky G had just gone for straight comedy, rather then lame love story it could have been great (like Tropic Thunder) but he’s got ugly man complex and thinks himself to be the next Billiam Murray so of course he’s going to keep pooping out these lame romantic comedies that just don’t work. Because lets face it, he’s not likable to the opposite sex. Its a fact that even all English lasses prefer the American Office as well.

  4. koutchboom says :

    Also that poster……ummmmm really Ricky G?????

  5. koutchboom says :

    also wouldn’t the world look different? Like there would be no art, so building would probably all be designed in the same way.

    I think another movie you can compare this too that handles it from a more dramatic side (and its Spidermans best performence) Pleasentville.

  6. Droid says :

    Yeah the look of the film is very sterile and unpleasant. Which is why I mentioned that the logic of the film is pretty faultless. But faultless logic is not worth it when you sacrifice enjoyment in a flick like this.

  7. Jarv says :

    I warned you about this. It’s terrible.

    You didn’t mention the only funny thing in it- the advertisements telling the truth- even if they did steal it straight from Crazy People with Dudley Moore in it.

  8. Droid says :

    I never listen to you. You should know that by now. I didn’t mention the ads because i tried not to ruin the few decent jokes in it.

  9. lord bronco says :

    He he-thanks for the heads up Droid-even when warned and the movie is described, with that talent-how could it be so unfunny…It’s obviously dumb in a world that logical-in any real human beings hands it would rapidly degenerate into a diabolical star trek episode. “You have cancer, and you’re going to die” or “God, is real, and he hates you”, the list goes on and on..oh well

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: